Why You Can't Let Go of What Happened (And How to Feel Safe Again)
You've been trying to move past what happened. Maybe for months, maybe for years. But something keeps pulling you back. Your body won't let go, even when you want it to.
A sound, a smell, a phrase someone says—and suddenly you're right back there. Your heart races. Your stomach drops. You feel tense, on edge, like something bad is about to happen, even when you know you're safe.
This isn't a weakness. This isn't you being dramatic or stuck in the past. This is your brain doing exactly what it was designed to do: remembering danger to keep you safe.
The problem is, it doesn't always know when to stop.
Why Your Brain Holds On So Tight
Your brain has one main job: keep you alive. And it takes that job very seriously.
When something scary or painful happens, your brain records everything about that moment—the sights, sounds, smells, and even how your body felt. It files this away as important information: "This meant danger. Remember this."
That's useful if you actually need to avoid real danger. But sometimes your brain keeps sounding the alarm long after the threat is gone. It treats reminders of what happened like the danger is still here, right now.
That's why:
A car backfiring can send you into panic mode
Certain places make you feel unsafe even though nothing is happening
You can't relax because your body is always waiting for the next bad thing
Your brain isn't broken. It's just stuck in protection mode.
Why "Just Let It Go" Doesn't Work
People might tell you to move on, think positively, or stop dwelling on the past. If only it were that easy.
You can't think your way out of this because the fear isn't living in the thinking part of your brain. It's deeper than that. It's in the part of your brain that reacts before you can even form a thought. This is a common trauma response, and it’s well-documented in how the brain processes danger.
That's why you can know you're safe and still feel terrified. Your thinking brain says, "There's no danger here." But your body says, "I don't believe you."
This is also why avoidance doesn't work. You might try to stay away from anything that reminds you of what happened. But the more you avoid, the more your brain learns that those things are still dangerous. The fear gets stronger, not weaker.
How Your Brain Can Learn Safety Again
Here's the good news: your brain can change. It's not stuck this way forever.
The same brain that learned to be afraid can also learn to feel safe again. But it doesn't happen by pretending the fear isn't there. It happens by teaching your brain a new story.
This is what that looks like:
Your brain learned: "This situation means danger."
Your brain can learn: "This situation used to mean danger, but it doesn't anymore."
Scientists call this "unlearning fear," but really it's about building something new. You're not erasing the memory. You're creating a stronger memory of safety that can compete with the fear.
Think of it like this: the fear is still there, but over time, the feeling of safety gets louder.
What Helps Your Brain Feel Safe
1. Learning what safety feels like in your body
After trauma, many people don't actually know what calm or safety feels like anymore. Therapy helps you notice small moments when your body settles, even briefly, so safety becomes something you can recognize, not just chase.
2. Borrowing regulation before creating your own
When someone else is calm and steady with you, your nervous system can begin to settle too. Over time, your body learns that it doesn't have to stay on high alert to survive.
3. Staying present while your body reacts
Healing isn't about avoiding reminders or pushing through them. It's about learning, with support, to stay connected to the present moment when your body reacts, rather than being pulled back into the past.
4. Building trust in your nervous system, not controlling it
The goal isn't to make fear disappear. It's to help your body trust that it can move through activation and come back to safety again.
5. Practicing all of this with guidance
A therapist helps pace the work so your system isn't overwhelmed. You don't have to figure out when to slow down or when to pause. That support is part of how safety is learned.
Why It Takes Time
If you've been trying to let go and it's not working, that doesn't mean you're failing. It means your brain needs more time and more support to build that safety.
Fear learned fast. Safety takes longer. That's not a flaw—it's how healing works.
And here's the thing: healing doesn't look the same for everyone. Some people need a few months. Some people need longer. What matters isn't how fast you go—it's that you keep moving forward, even if it's slow.
When You Need More Than Tips
Sometimes the fear is so deep, or the reminders are so constant, that self-help strategies alone aren't enough. If you've been trying to feel safe again and it's not happening, that might mean you need support specifically for trauma. There's no shame in that. Some things are too heavy to carry alone.
Therapy can help you:
Understand why your body reacts the way it does
Practice feeling safe in a controlled environment
Build new patterns slowly, without overwhelming you
Process what happened in a way that doesn't keep retraumatizing you
You don't have to have all the answers. You just have to be willing to try.
You're Not Stuck Forever
What happened to you was real. The fear you feel is real. But it doesn't have to control the rest of your life.
Your brain can learn safety again. It just needs time, support, and repetition. Little by little, the fear can get quieter. Little by little, you can start to feel like yourself again.
It won't happen overnight. But it can happen.
You Don't Have to Do This Alone
At Walk With Me Counseling Center, we work with people who are trying to feel safe again after trauma. We offer virtual therapy across Illinois, including Chicago.
Healing takes time, but you don't have to figure it out on your own.
📞 Schedule a Free Consultation
